Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > Cricket > India's tour of West Indies > UNI > Report

Under fire over Dhoni's dismissal, ICC issues protocol

June 14, 2006 13:14 IST

Under criticism from all quarters following Mahendra Singh Dhoni's bizarre dismissal in the first India-West Indies Test match, the International Cricket Council has clarified its protocol in this connection, and admitted that the decision had left the players frustrated in the Antigua Test.

The protocol regarding situations where a boundary decision and a catch decision or a boundary decision and a runout are components of the same incident has also been issued to all members of the Emirates Elite Panel of ICC Umpires.

According to this protocol, when a batsman hits the ball in the air to a fielder near the boundary and the on-field umpires are uncertain whether a catch has been completed or a boundary scored, the on-field umpires are entitled to refer the boundary decision to the TV umpire in accordance with Clause 3.2.4 of the ICC Playing Conditions. Once the boundary decision request has been referred to him, the TV umpire has the responsibility to make a decision solely on whether a boundary has been scored, the release said.

''If the TV replay evidence is inconclusive, the TV umpire must still make a boundary decision. His decision must be made using the existing convention in cricket which dictates that the status quo prevails -- ie, because no evidence exists of a boundary being scored, no boundary is awarded.

''This decision is conveyed back to the on-field umpires. In these circumstances, as no boundary has been scored, the only decision left is for the on-field umpire at the bowler's end to give the batsman out -- caught,'' it added.

The same protocol would apply to a runout decision in circumstances where it is questionable whether a boundary has been scored. In such circumstances, the TV umpire must first make a decision on that boundary. Once this decision has been made the on-field umpires can then decide whether or not to refer the runout appeal to the TV umpire. The decision on the boundary must be made using the existing convention in cricket and the boundary and runout issues should be dealt with as separate considerations, the protocol states.

In the Dhoni incident, the wicket-keeper/batsman was caught on the boundary line by Daren Ganga, who apparently looked like he had stepped on the rope, and the on-field umpires referred the decision to third umpire Bill Doctrove who took 15 minutes and was still without a verdict.

Captain Brian Lara then convinced Dhoni to walk off, and the incident sparked off a widespread debate over the manner in which the Indian was given out.

ICC's General Manager - Cricket David Richardson said, ''The confusion in Antigua arose over what the third umpire was required to adjudicate on -- a boundary or a dismissal.

''That confusion created understandable frustration among players and spectators and the clarification of this protocol should ensure a similar situation does not arise in the future.''

India's tour of West Indies: The Complete Coverage

Would you like to join the Cricket and Cricket Lovers Discussion Group and discuss your cricket views with other cricket freaks? Click here. Have fun!


Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 3

Sub: Re: ICC issues protocol

"...His decision must be made using the existing convention in cricket which dictates that the status quo prevails -- ie, because no evidence exists of ...

Posted by Sanj

Sub: ICC issues new protocol

There are two issues here: Whether this is a dismissal or not: TV replays were inconclusive on whether the fielder crossed the ropes or not. ...

Posted by Bharat Paliwal

Sub: Protocol to defend Lara?

The thumb rule we have always been hearing about is: "Benefit of doubt should be given to batsman" This means if you are uncertain on ...

Posted by Tushar