Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections

Search:



The Web

India Abroad




Newsletters
Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > Business > Special


'The largest mass migration in history is unfolding in India'

Suman Guha Mozumder in New York | October 19, 2006

Related Articles
Floundering on founding myths
Image: Arundhati Roy leads Kerala farmer widows
The State of Non-compliance
Vidarbha: 7 farmers commit suicide
More reports from Maharashtra
'Vidarbha is culturally different'
PM to monitor Vidarbha development plans
Wellknown journalist P Sainath told an audience in New York on Wednesday that while food courts are springing up almost everywhere in India's big city malls catering to the palates of well-off Indians, an average family in the country's rural areas has less to eat today than it had six years ago.

"The average rural family today is eating nearly 100 grams less of foodgrains than six or seven years ago and the average per capita availability of food grains has declined sharply. In 1991, when reforms began, availability of food per person was 510 grams, today it has fallen to 437 grams," Sainath said.

"At a time when people of our class are eating foods like we never had in our lives before, India's agriculture sector is in the midst of a collapse," Sainath said while speaking on 'India's Brave New World: The Agrarian Crisis, Farm Suicides and the Wages Of Inequality,' hosted by the South Asian Journalists Association in New York.

Giving snapshots of what he described was the spectacular inequality that has been growing faster in the past 15 years in India than at any time since the country was colonised by the British, Sainath said while India has eight billionaires and hundreds of millionaires, the country ranks 127th in the Human Development Report Index. Labour productivity has been 84 per cent in a period of reform during which real wages dropped to 24 per cent.

"So, on the one hand we have this incredible emerging tiger economy. . . (on the other hand) it should be remembered that the incredible tiger economy produces a very shameful kind of human development indicators," Sainath said.

"The life expectancy of average Indians is lower than people in Mongolia or Tajikistan. Per capita GDP might be booming at a growth rate which is astonishing but our per capita GDP is lower than that of Nicaragua, Vanuatu or Indonesia and the farm sector is in the midst of most incredible crisis that you can imagine," he said.

He said the Vidarbha region in Maharashtra has seen 968 suicides by farmers, including 120 on an average every month in the last three months. In March, Parliament was told by Union Agriculture Minister Sharad Pawar that in the last ten years over 120,000 farmers have committed suicide in India.

"Suicides by farmers today are actually a symptom of a much wider crisis in India's farm and agricultural sector," Sainath said, adding that this was the result not of a natural calamity or some accident but a systematic and structured move to shift to corporate farming from small family farming practices as well as mindless deregulation that has ruined the farming community. "You get a picture of India in Vidarbha."

Without saying so in as many words, Sainath ripped apart the claims of the present and the previous governments that the country as a whole is making progress and reaping the benefits of development for all sections of the people.

Reeling out figures and statistics from the National Sample Survey Organisation as well as other government outfits, he said, "The claims that India is shining are true. I believe it, although it is happening for just the ten percent of the population."

"If you talk about the top section of the population, the benchmark today are the US, Western Europe, Japan and Australia, but if you look at the bottom part of the population, the benchmark is sub-Saharan Africa, even there some of the countries provide a better level of nutrition to their people than India does," he said.

Sainath -- the first reporter in the world to win Amnesty International's Global Human Rights Journalism Award in its inaugural year, 2000, and who was awarded the Judge's Prize in the Harry Chapin Media Awards in the newspaper category in 2006 -- said that for any real solution of the farmers' problems, the long-term land-related issues need to be solved.

"It is an explosive situation in India today as far as agriculture is concerned and the farmers are concerned with the employment rates in rural areas being the lowest since the late 1990s. We keep hearing about huge displacements due to dam-building or canal-digging, but let me tell you the biggest displacement is in agriculture where the largest mass migration in the history is beginning to unfold following displacement of people from their land," he said.


More Specials

Share your comments


 What do you think about the story?




Read what others have to say:


Number of User Comments: 18




Sub: India,s shocking neglect of its farmers

Many of the comments in the message columns are right. I don't accept some of the views of the author regarding availability of the food ...


Posted by P.Shivakumar





Sub: Indi's neglect of its farmers

It seems that the speech of Mr. Sainath is anti-Indian with lots of fake quotes. Indeed the India is fastest growing country. The situation of ...


Posted by Tejas Raval





Sub: India's neglect of its farmers

Sir: An extremely bold and incisive analysis that will be hated by the Great Powers like Manmohan Singh, P Chidambaram, and Montek Singh Ahluwalia. The ...


Posted by Rajesh Vyas





Sub: Now every Indian has to think about helping our farmers & agriculture sector in India..

Good that notorious people started bringing farmers real problems in India so that govt will realize and bring some reforms to uplift the sector. And ...


Posted by Narendra Gurram





Sub: Shame on Congress & BJP

If it was "India Shining" by the former, it is "India Growing" current Government but as Author puts out, it is just for 10% of ...


Posted by Prem




Disclaimer


Advertisement






Copyright © 2006 Rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.